I'm going to start this review by clarifying that I have a lean, narrow foot. I have a C toe and a B heel. So this review is biased towards a narrow foot. That being said, I have tried about twenty different sandals to find a couple that fit reasonably snug. So for comparison purposes this may be a useful guide for people. My preferences are light weight, comfortable, with a heel strike that has some padding. I also like moderate arch support. I don't want a lot of flop in my flip. I don't want a negative heel. I'm going to list the sandals I've tried, and give a brief comparison, which should be helpful to everyone. I'll start with this one:
Teva Mush ll - (9) These are by far the lightest of the bunch, weighing in at a mere 92g each. They're also comfortable with a fairly narrow footbed and a snug thong. So, yes, I love these. And at $25 they are a bargain, even though they won't last as long as some of the more expensive sandals here. The middle of the heel-strike is a little harder than the surrounding area and some people have complained about it, but I haven't been bothered by it in the short periods of time I've spent in them.
Reef Mens Leather Fanning ll - (9 Mens) These are the heaviest of all the sandals I've tried, weighing in at 219 grams each. The footbed is comfortable but more firm than some of the others. Nice looking. They have an average fit, (fairly snug), but they were a little lose on me. I think these would last a long time. Unlike with the Reef Draftsman, I did not feel the bottle opener under my arch. Comfortable, but expensive and heavy.
Reef Leather Slap ll - (Mens 9) Oddly, this sandal was a full size shorter than any other Reefs I tried, (A full 1/2 inch), so order up. They weighed in at 205 grams each, making them the second heaviest in this comparison. Had they been the same size as the Fanning ll's they would have been the heaviest. Average fit. These are one of the most comfortable sandals in this line-up. Very cushy heel.
Reef Phantom LE - (Mens 9) This leather sandal is much lighter, weighing in at 142g. Somewhat more snug fitting than average. Very comfortable and attractive. Reasonably priced. This pair was a keeper for me.
Reef Phantom Prints - (9) Weighing in at 113g, these were the second lightest sandal of the bunch. Snug fitting and comfortable, these are my personal favorites. Reasonably soft heel-strike with an average width footbed and just the right amount of arch support. They won't likely last as long as some of the heavier sandals, but they can be had for half the cost. I've seen them for $20 on up, depending on color and size.
Reef Phantoms - (Mens 10) These synthetic sandals seem to be made elsewhere from the other two Phantoms listed above. The fit is much different. They are wider in the footbed and sloppy fitting. These are made for a wide foot. Again, they are fairly light, weighing in at 134g, and I got these a full size up from the other two because everyone said they ran small. I think they run just a half size smaller.
Reef Draftsman - (9) This is a leather sandal with no additional heel support. It also has a bottle opener on the bottom. Nice looking, fairly snug fitting, and fairly light, (About 156g) but this sandal has an issue. As others have indicated, you can feel the bottle opener under your arch. I don't think anyone would be comfortable in these for long. I sent these back.
Reef Crew - (9) This leather sandal is fairly light at 138g each. They have a slender footbed and a somewhat snug fit. I like that, however, there is no additional heel support and they run as high as $60.
Reef Twinpin - (9) These basic synthetic leather sandals are fairly light at 137g each, and they have a slender footbed, but the thong is very lose and has no additional heel-strike.
Sanuk Fraid So - (10) These sandals weighed in at a modest 139g each and were really comfortable and attractive. I loved this sandal. Unfortunately, they have a very wide footbed and a very lose fitting thong. Yep, fraid so. But if you have fat feet, you'll love these.
Sanuk M Fraid - (9) These leather/poly sandals weighed in at 175g each, making them one of the heavier sandals here. They have a slender footbed, (A full half inch thinner than the Fraid So), but with a sloppy thong.
Sanuk Beer Cozy - (9) This fabric sandal has a wide footbed and a sloppy thong, but weighed in at a respectable 134g each. These have a very cushy, comfortable footbed. People rave about how comfortable they are. But you need to have fat or wide feet. Dang!
Teva Men's Classic - (9) This is a very basic, uninspired sandal with a ruff, heavily textured, old school footbed. Perfect for some people, but I found them uncomfortable. It's light, but not as light as the Mush ll's. The thong was more loose than the Mush ll and it runs a little more money.
Teva Mush ll (Canvas) (9) I listed these as well because the canvas thong fits more loosely than the regular Mush ll's and weighed a little more. Other than that they have the same footbed.
Add a debit or credit card to save time when you check out
Convenient and secure with 2 clicks. Add your card
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Videos
Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1
Videos for this product
1:01
Click to play video
Wowzas my thoughts on the mushy quality
Jessica Peterson
Reviews with images
Comfortable, but a bit slippery and much thinner than expected
I am a female wearing women's size 8 in flip flops, and it usually translates to size 6 in men's. I got these Teva Mush II men's flip flops in size 7, and they fit just fine. Both length and width are perfect. The insole is non-slippery suede like material, however, the bottom sole is very plastic-y and slippery. They are thinner and less squishy than I expected.The insole is not very soft, although it's sufficient for most people who don't have achy feet or plantar fasciitis. I do, however, have PF and my feet are usually in pain. I wish these were a little squishier on the inside, like the orange flip flops (Pevino brand, sold by Amazon). They are comfortable for short walks and around the house, but I couldn't wear them on lengthy walks without experiencing pain. They are starting to flatten under my heel already, and I only wore them a couple of times.The straps are a perfect length (I have somewhat wide feet with a high arch) and non-scratchy, and so is the thong part that goes between the toes.
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on November 6, 2016
Reviewed in the United States on October 30, 2023
The insole is not very soft, although it's sufficient for most people who don't have achy feet or plantar fasciitis. I do, however, have PF and my feet are usually in pain. I wish these were a little squishier on the inside, like the orange flip flops (Pevino brand, sold by Amazon). They are comfortable for short walks and around the house, but I couldn't wear them on lengthy walks without experiencing pain. They are starting to flatten under my heel already, and I only wore them a couple of times.
The straps are a perfect length (I have somewhat wide feet with a high arch) and non-scratchy, and so is the thong part that goes between the toes.
Size: 7Color: Quincy Dark GreyVerified Purchase
Comfortable, but a bit slippery and much thinner than expected
Reviewed in the United States on October 30, 2023
I am a female wearing women's size 8 in flip flops, and it usually translates to size 6 in men's. I got these Teva Mush II men's flip flops in size 7, and they fit just fine. Both length and width are perfect. The insole is non-slippery suede like material, however, the bottom sole is very plastic-y and slippery. They are thinner and less squishy than I expected.Reviewed in the United States on October 30, 2023
The insole is not very soft, although it's sufficient for most people who don't have achy feet or plantar fasciitis. I do, however, have PF and my feet are usually in pain. I wish these were a little squishier on the inside, like the orange flip flops (Pevino brand, sold by Amazon). They are comfortable for short walks and around the house, but I couldn't wear them on lengthy walks without experiencing pain. They are starting to flatten under my heel already, and I only wore them a couple of times.
The straps are a perfect length (I have somewhat wide feet with a high arch) and non-scratchy, and so is the thong part that goes between the toes.
Images in this review
Top reviews from other countries
El pinche Jimmy
Garantía
Reviewed in Mexico on November 16, 2023Size: 12Color: Raki Dark DenimVerified Purchase
Erkin
Super comfortable
Reviewed in Canada on September 1, 2023Size: 9Color: Chocolate BrownVerified Purchase
Rcisreg
Fits as expected and very comfortable
Reviewed in Canada on August 24, 2022Size: 10Color: Raki Dark DenimVerified Purchase
Amazon Customer
Amazon Size Chart incorrect!!
Reviewed in Canada on March 23, 2022Size: 11Color: Brick BlackVerified Purchase
Amazon Customer
Reviewed in Canada on March 23, 2022
Images in this review
Eric Bighouse
Très confortable !
Reviewed in Canada on September 3, 2021Size: 7Color: Brick BlackVerified Purchase
